Complaint concerning dismissal without just and sufficient cause
Workers who have been employed by the same employer for at least 2 years may file a complaint if they believe their employer has dismissed them without just cause.
An employer may terminate a worker's employment. This is part of the exercise of their right to manage. However, if a dispute is to be decided by a judge after a termination, layoff or dismissal, the employer must be able to show that there are just and sufficient grounds for their decision.
Some situations may be considered a dismissal without just and sufficient cause.
Sophie has held the same job for 5 years. Her employer dismisses her, claiming economic difficulties. A few days later, Sophie learns that her employer hired another person, at the same wage, to perform the exact same tasks that she had been doing.
Sophie could file a complaint for dismissal without just and sufficient cause. The employer cannot invoke termination for economic reasons, since they replaced Sophie.
Other situations could be considered a dismissal without just and sufficient cause, including a constructive dismissal or a double sanction.
Constructive dismissal is a roundabout way for an employer to dismiss a worker by presenting the end of employment as a termination or layoff. The worker may also be forced to resign owing to significant and unjustified changes in their working conditions or owing to various forms of harassment.
- Patrick has been working as a mechanic 40 hours a week for 10 years. He has always worked full time Monday to Friday from 8:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m. at an hourly rate of $22.00. His employer tells him that, from now on, he will work 20 hours a week from Monday to Friday from 1:00 p.m. to 5:00 p.m. at an hourly rate of $15.
- It could be a case of constructive dismissal. The changes are significant and could force Patrick to leave his job to find working conditions equivalent to those he had before.
An employer may not reprimand a worker twice for the same mistake. For example, if an employer suspends a worker for a mistake they made, the employer may not subsequently decide to dismiss the worker for the same reason.
- Carl has been working as a plant storekeeper for 10 years. His employer accuses him of making a mistake when placing an order and suspends him for 5 days. This is the first time Carl has ever been accused of making a mistake and disciplined. During his suspension, he receives a registered letter informing him of his dismissal.
- This is a double sanction and, therefore, a dismissal without just and sufficient cause since, for the same mistake, the employer first suspended Carl and then dismissed him.
- What does not constitute dismissal without just and sufficient cause
Anne has been a representative for a cosmetics company for 5 years. During a meeting, her employer informs her that she is being suspended pending an investigation into allegations of theft. The results of the investigation lead to the conclusion that Anne had indeed committed theft. Her employer meets with her again to dismiss her.
The dismissal is justified and is not a double sanction, since the employer waited for the results of the investigation before deciding to dismiss Anne.
Maxime has been working for the same company for 3 years. His employer, facing serious economic difficulties, had to lay off several employees. Maxime is dismissed along with all his coworkers who have the same number of years of uninterrupted service.
This is an unfortunate but legal termination. The employer is experiencing real economic difficulties and Maxime is not the only one to have lost his job.
Claudie has been a secretary/receptionist for 4 years. She has always worked 40 hours a week, 36 hours during the day and 4 hours one evening a week. Due to a decline in business, her employer decides to no longer open in the evenings. As a result, the employer has to change Claudie's schedule to 36 hours a week. Claudie claims it is a constructive dismissal.
This is not a constructive dismissal, since no major changes were made to Claudie's working conditions.
How the complaints process works
Filing a complaint
The worker has 45 days from the date of their dismissal to file their complaint.
Analysis of the complaint
Transfer of the file to the CNESST’s legal affairs department
A complaint concerning dismissal without just and sufficient cause is heard by the Tribunal administratif du travail.
If the judge determines that the complaint is founded, they may:
- order the employer to reinstate the worker in the job they held before their dismissal
- order the employer to pay the worker an indemnity equivalent to the wages lost since their dismissal
- render any other decision they consider fair and reasonable